"There absolutely can be evils acts. And there are evil or bad acts that can be committed by good people. We see that all the time. I see all these wrongful convictions, and I see all these people who have power, whether they are police or prosecutors, who really believe that they are good people, who have the authority and who begin to believe that if they decide somebody is guilty or has done something wrong, they are so righteous themselves and have done so much good in the world and avenged so much evil that their actions can't be questioned. And even more than that - that it's okay for them to bury exculpatory evidence, or to take shortcuts, to not follow fair process, to not even consider that they might be wrong because they are so good. Those people with that kind of self-righteousness very often commit acts of evil. And by evil I mean not just being wrong but doing things that are malicious. Gratuitously nasty.
"I look at evil
acts, acts of malice, as opposed to a notion of evil as a force, as if there's something inside of people that inexorably leads them to take malicious, horrible, hurtful actions. There may very well be. I think that's an important distinction, because I see people all the time who, by an definition, describe themselves as good, and maybe in many other aspects of their lives you would not take issue with anything they do. They're good servants of the community, they're good to members of their family, they are, in many instances, very religious in the best of ways - kindness and charity and giving and good acts towards others - and almost
because of their self-righteous belief that anything they do is good, they do evil."
-Barry Scheck, Attorney, in an interview with Cathleen Falsani, February 2005;
from The God FactorI won't lie: I think I'm a good person. I like to think I'm average or above-average in most categories, with the exception of height. I'm not really sure what I'm basing my judgments on, though, because I know for fact that I also do bad things. I don't know if I'd call them
evil... but I guess that is, again, because I consider myself good - perhaps too good to be evil.
The words spoken by Scheck struck a chord within me as I was reading them today, emphasizing two things for me: that the distinction between a person and a person's actions is something we need to, but often forget to make; and that bad things - maybe even evil things - happen when people assume themselves to be good.
Through the psych courses I took at school, I learned all about the power of situation in determining people's actions and reactions, but also how people are the sum of their habits or actions or something. Even though I had a lot of theoretical knowledge about social psychology, it was still a struggle to learn to separate who people
are from the things that they do. Personally I find it makes more sense only going one way: people who do bad things may not automatically be bad people, but how can people who do good things not be good people? I guess people can do good things for wrong motives, but I don't think it makes them
bad, because they still
did good. I actually wonder if there is such thing as a wrong motive for doing good.
That being said, I suppose it's how people arrive at the conclusion that they're good: because they do good things - for their family, their community, etc. But in order to arrive at said conclusion, people usually have to ignore all the bad stuff they did do. That's easily done by compartmentalizing our life, or placing less importance on the area what we're weak in. And especially if bad things are done in secret, nobody has to know, nobody gets hurt, and we can still see ourselves as good people.
When we start feeling too good about ourselves, our pride consumes us and we inevitably do bad, whether to ourselves or to others. When I thought I had everything under control and thought I was too smart to ask people for advice, I ended up doing and putting up with a lot of stuff I wish I hadn't. When we start taking emphasizing our own importance and worth over others', we damage relationships with coworkers, with friends and with family.
Nowadays people are expected to have a healthy dose of self-confidence. We learn to sell ourselves in job or school interviews, to impress friends or parents or [future] in-laws, and so on. It is so hard to reconcile that notion with the fact that Jesus, God incarnate, who died for the sins of the world, never assumed himself to be anything greater than a servant. In light of that...
Who am I to assume myself to be anything great at all?
Lyrics from a song by Watermark pop into my head now: "Who am I, that You would love me so gently? Who am I, that You would recognize my name? Lord, who am I, that You would speak to me so softly? Conversation with the Love most high... Who am I?"
I wrote in the cover letter of my job application to Evergreen that one thing I wanted to learn more about through working there, was humility. Clearly that is a journey that will stretch for far longer than a summer.